A major issue in the 2020 Election is health care, and Democratic voters seem to be reassessing their approach to this hot button topic.
Health Care And 2020 Election
Democrats Take A Look At A Practical Health Care Approach
By MICHELLE L. PRICE and RICARDO ALONSO-ZALDIVAR Associated Press
LAS VEGAS (AP) — Democratic voters appear to be reassessing their approach to health care, a pragmatic shift on their party's top 2020 issue.
While "Medicare for All" remains hugely popular, majorities say they'd prefer building on "Obamacare" to expand coverage instead of a new government program that replaces America's mix of private and public insurance.
Highlighted by a recent national poll, shifting views are echoed in interviews with voters and the evolving positions of Democratic presidential candidates on a proposal that months ago seemed to have growing momentum within their party. Several have endorsed an incremental approach rather than a government-run plan backed by Sens. Bernie Sanders of Vermont and Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts.
It could mean trouble for Sanders and his supporters, signaling a limit to how far Democratic voters are willing to move to the left and an underlying skepticism that Americans will back such a dramatic change to their health care.
"We hear Medicare for All, but I'm not absolutely certain what that means and what that would then mean for me," said Democrat Terrie Dietrich, who lives near Las Vegas. "Does it mean that private insurance is gone forever?"
Dietrich, 74, has Medicare and supplements that with private insurance, an arrangement she said she's pretty comfortable with.
She thinks it's important that everyone has health care, not just those who can afford it. She said she would support Medicare for All if it was the only way to achieve that.
But "I don't think we can ever get it passed," Dietrich added.
Erin Cross, her 54-year-old daughter and also a Democrat, said she's not comfortable with switching to a system in which a government plan is the only choice. She said Democrats won't be able to appeal to Republicans unless they strike a middle ground and allow people to keep their private insurance.
"We've got to get some of these other people, these Republican voters, to come on over just to get rid of Trump," she said.
Democratic presidential candidates also have expressed skepticism.
California Sen. Kamala Harris' new plan would preserve a role for private insurance. New Jersey Sen. Cory Booker is open to step-by-step approaches. Meanwhile, health care moderates including former Vice President Joe Biden have been blunt in criticizing the government-run system envisioned by Sanders.
In Nevada, the early voting swing state that tests presidential candidates' appeal to labor and a diverse population, moderate Democrats have won statewide by focusing on health care affordability and preserving protections from President Barack Obama's law.
Nationwide, 55% of Democrats and independents who lean Democratic said in a poll last month they'd prefer building on Obama's Affordable Care Act instead of replacing it with Medicare for All. The survey by the nonpartisan Kaiser Family Foundation found 39% would prefer Medicare for All. Majorities of liberals and moderates concurred.
On a separate question, Democratic support for Medicare for All was a robust 72% in July, but that was down from 80% in April, a drop Kaiser says is statistically significant but not necessarily a definitive downward trend.
That said, Kaiser pollster Liz Hamel said it wouldn't be surprising if it turned into one. On big health care ideas, she said, "as the public starts seeing arguments for and against, we often see movement."
The Kaiser survey also found broad backing for the public-option alternative that moderates are touting, a government plan that would compete with but not replace private insurance. Eight-five percent of Democrats supported that idea, along with 68% of independents. Republicans were opposed, 62% to 36%.
Large increases in federal spending and a significant expansion of government power are often cited as arguments against Medicare for All. However, the main criticism Democrats are hearing from some of their own candidates is that the Sanders plan would force people to give up their private health insurance. Under the Vermont senator's legislation, it would be unlawful for insurers or employers to offer coverage for benefits provided by the new government plan.
Ohio Rep. Tim Ryan argued during the last round of Democratic debates that that's problematic for union members with hard-fought health care plans secured by sacrificing wage increases. However, Sanders has long asserted his plan will allow unions to obtain bigger wage increases by taking health care out of the equation.
In interviews with The Associated Press, union workers in Nevada said they worried about how Medicare for All would affect their coverage.
Chad Neanover, prep cook at the Margaritaville casino-restaurant on the Las Vegas Strip, said he would be reluctant to give up the comprehensive insurance that his union has fought to keep. He has asthma, and his wife is dealing with diabetes. The union's plan has no monthly premium cost and no deductible.
"I don't want to give up my health insurance. I've personally been involved in the fight to keep it," said Neanover, 44. "A lot of people have fought to have what we have today."
Savannah Palmira, a 34-year-old union construction worker in Las Vegas, said she's open to supporting Medicare for All, but wants to know specifically what it would look like, how the country would transition and how it would affect her plan.
"That's one of the biggest things that I love about being in the union, is our quality health care," Palmira said.
Medicare for All backers say their plan has been unfairly portrayed.
"The shift in polling on Medicare for All is a direct result of mischaracterizations by opponents," said Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., a Sanders campaign co-chair.
People are most interested in keeping their own doctors, Khanna added, and Medicare for All would not interfere with that.
Longtime watchers of America's health care debate see new energy among Democrats, along with a familiar pattern.
"The long-standing history of health reform is that people want to hang on to what they have," said Georgetown University public policy professor Judith Feder, who was a health policy adviser in the Clinton administration.
Nonetheless, she noted a common interest among Democrats: "People want affordable, reliable, stable coverage."
___
Alonso-Zaldivar reported from Washington.
Hispanic Outlook is an education magazine in the US available both in print and digital form. Visit https://www.hispanicoutlook.com/education-magazine for information about our latest issue, including our new supplement Physician Outlook.
Hispanic Outlook’s Job Board allows applicants to search for jobs by category, by city and by state. Both Featured and Latest Job Positions are available at https://hispanicoutlookjobs.com/
And for employers, Hispanic Outlook’s Job Board offers a wide variety of posting options. Further information is available at https://hispanicoutlookjobs.com/employer-products/
Other articles from Hispanic Outlook:
Is There A Doctor…Anywhere?
Perhaps this has happened to you (and if it hasn't, it might happen soon). You need to see a Doctor, but you’re told you can’t see the Doctor for weeks or maybe even a month. Or maybe your trusted family Doctor has either moved away, died or retired, and an all-purpose medical group has moved into that office. More than likely you’ll have to get used to seeing non-Doctors including nurses and APNs for routine office visits. Unless the projected Physician shortage is reversed, that’s the future of medical care. If that doesn’t sound wrong, how would you feel if you were on trial in a case where your life, liberty or livelihood was on the line, and the only person you could find to argue on your behalf was a paralegal, not a licensed attorney? Unlike an attorney, every time you see a Doctor there’s a chance that his or her skills will discover and treat something that would otherwise severely impact...
Read full article here
Graduating More Latino Doctors
In the 2003 landmark Supreme Court decision on affirmative action at the University of Michigan Justice Sandra Day O’Connor wrote, “We expect that 25 years from now, the use of racial preferences will no longer be necessary to further the interest approved today.” Since that 2003 decision, the United States has made little progress in the areas Justice O’Connor had hoped, says Jorge Girotti, director, The Hispanic Center of Excellence at the University of Illinois College of Medicine. In fact, it appears the country is moving backwards, he added. Statistics suggest that most U.S. medical schools can just attract, enroll or graduate significant numbers of Latinos. In the 2018-19 school year Latinos comprised only 6.4% of students enrolled in U.S. medical schools. Some schools, however, are the exception. The University of Illinois College of Medicine, for...
Read full article here
Social Media Take On Bogus Vaccine Claims
NEW YORK (AP) — Like health officials facing measles outbreaks, internet companies are trying to contain vaccine-related misinformation they have long helped spread. So far, their efforts at quarantine are falling short. The digital scrapbooking site Pinterest—which has been a leading online repository of vaccine misinformation—in 2017 took the seemingly drastic step of blocking all searches for the term “vaccines,” affecting even legitimate searches for information. It was part of the company’s enforcement of a broader policy against health misinformation. But it’s been a leaky quarantine. Recently, a search for “measles vaccine” still brought up, among other things, a post titled “Why We Said NO to the Measles Vaccine,” along with a sinister-looking illustration of a hand holding an enormous needle titled...
Read full article here
Physicians Sound Health Care Alarm
Editor’s Note: Bipartisan Physicians and health care experts gathered at the Free to Care Physician Symposium in Washington, D.C., earlier this year. A white paper1 offering a roadmap drawn by a coalition of organizations made up of working Physicians and industry experts entitled, “Reducing Cost and Waste in American Medicine A Physician-Led Roadmap to Patient-Centered Medical Care,” was presented by authors C. L. Gray, M.D., founder, Physicians for Reform2 and Marion Mass, M.D. co-founder, Practicing Physicians of America3. The following is an abridged version of the white papers premise: “The cost of medical care—and access to medical care itself—now sit atop the list of worries for American households. In years past, the debate over healthcare reform centered on the autonomy of individual patients and their physicians. Who should control the personal and complex process of…
Read full article here
Adding Insult To Injury
Imagine having a job you love. Imagine it’s a job you spent years preparing for and took on a huge student debt just so you could fulfill your dream of having this particular career. Now imagine that each and every day you live with the stress that one false move, action or misinterpreted word could risk everything you own and your ability to continue to do what you love. That’s the occupational hazard of being a Doctor. Law enforcement professionals and firefighters face jeopardy that is obvious and acknowledged by society—and even honored. But the Physician is often not viewed with much sympathy. For Patients who are unhappy with their medical treatment for a variety of reasons from the benign (having unreasonable expectations about the progress and extent of recovery) to the malignant (“wrong” diagnosis, medical device failure or pharmaceutical complications…
Read full article here
Physician Spotlight: Dr. Daniel Olivero, M.D.
Dr. Daniel Olivero, whose family is from Dominican Republic, grew up in a South Bronx housing project. It was a place where parents’ aspirations for their children were basic—stay alive and don’t join a gang. He has, by all measures, wildly surpassed those modest expectations. “After undergrad, I worked for four years in a very comfortable, but very boring, office job,” Dr. Olivero explained, “I was bored and wanted an intellectual challenge, so I decided to go to med school in Dominican Republic.” It was a decision that brought him this welcomed challenge and his life’s passion. Dedicated to the health and wellness of infants and children, Dr. Olivero is a board-certified pediatrician and has served on the Board of Directors of the Lewisburg Children’s Museum as chair of health education. Dr. Olivero is dually board certified in addiction Medicine and is the...
Read full article here
Doctors Weigh In On New Green Card Rule
CHICAGO (AP) — Diabetics skipping regular checkups. Young asthmatics not getting preventive care. A surge in expensive emergency room visits. Doctors and public health experts warn of poor health and rising costs they say will come from sweeping Trump administration changes that would deny green cards to many immigrants who use Medicaid, as well as food stamps and other forms of public assistance. Some advocates say they're already seeing the fallout even before the complex 837-page rule takes effect in October. President Donald Trump's administration trumpeted its aggressive approach this past week as a way to keep only self-sufficient immigrants in the country, but health experts argue it could force potentially millions of low-income migrants to choose between needed services and their bid to stay legally in the U.S. "People are going to be sicker. They're not going to go get health care, or not until they have to go to an emergency room," said Lisa David, president and CEO of Public Health Solutions, New York's largest…
Read full article here
