By replacing the Environmental Context Dashboard with a tool that doesn’t reduce an applicant's background to a single number, the SAT will no longer have the “adversity score.”
No More SAT 'Adversity Score'
College Board Says It Is Replacing SAT 'Adversity Score'
By CAROLYN THOMPSON Associated Press
The company that administers the SAT college admissions test is replacing the so-called adversity score with a tool that will no longer reduce an applicant's background to a single number, an idea the College Board's chief executive now says was a mistake.
Amid growing scrutiny of the role wealth plays in college admissions, the College Board introduced its Environmental Context Dashboard about two years ago to provide context for a student's performance on the test and help schools identify those who have done more with less.
The version used by about 50 institutions in a pilot program involved a formula that combined school and neighborhood factors like advanced course offerings and the crime rate to produce a single number.
But critics called it an overreach for the College Board to score adversity the way it does academics.
David Coleman, College Board's chief executive, said some also wrongly worried the tool would alter the SAT results.
"The idea of a single score was wrong," he said. "It was confusing and created the misperception that the indicators are specific to an individual student."
The New York City-based College Board announced several changes to the tool Tuesday, including the decision to give students access to the information about their schools and neighborhood starting in the 2020-2021 school year.
Renamed "Landscape," the revised tool will provide data points from government sources and the College Board that are seen as affecting education. They include whether the student's school is rural, suburban or urban, the size of the school's senior class, the percentage of students eligible for free- and reduced-price lunch, and participation and performance in college-level Advanced Placement courses at the school.
Admissions officers also will see a range of test scores at the school to show where the applicant's falls, as well as information like the median family income, education levels and crime rates in the student's neighborhood.
The tool's creation was an acknowledgment of persistent criticism of the use of admissions tests in an era of concern with unequal access to advanced coursework and high-priced tutors that further advantage those with the means to access them.
This year's "Varsity Blues" scandal , which exposed cases of affluent parents cheating the admissions system, has brought further scrutiny.
Colleges and universities have for several years been acting on the concerns, with an increasing number no longer demanding SAT or rival ACT scores from applicants. More than 1,000 schools, including elite liberal arts colleges, as well as research universities and for-profit schools, are test-optional, according to the nonprofit group FairTest, which argues standardized tests are biased against minority groups.
Yale University piloted the Environmental Context Dashboard, and admissions dean Jeremiah Quinlan said it's a consistent way to see information that its admissions officers have always considered when culling through an application pool of 38,000.
Just over 1,500 students recently arrived for their first year, more than 20% of them eligible for income-based federal Pell Grants, he said. That compares with about 16% before the dashboard and 12% six years ago.
"It helps us identify students who have excelled in their context in a more clear and convincing way than we ever could have in the past," said Quinlan, dean of undergraduate admissions and financial aid.
Eddie Comeaux, vice chair of the University of California's Board of Admissions and Relations with Schools, said the improved clarity and transparency of Landscape addressed some of his initial concerns.
He still worries, though, about potential implicit bias among admissions officers, a problem that predates the context tool and is a focus of his work on the board, which regulates admissions practices.
"We want to look at implicit bias training and the ways in which certain indicators might signal a way in which (application) readers advantage or disadvantage certain applications and consciously or unconsciously not be aware of it," he said.
"I'm less concerned about Landscape," he said, "than I am about those who are making the decisions utilizing Landscape."
Between 100 and 150 institutions are expected to pilot the new tool this year before it becomes broadly available next year.
In addition to bringing our readers stories about education issues in America, we here at Hispanic Outlook feature news articles on topics both related to and outside of the field of education on our website and in our social media.
Hispanic Outlook is an education magazine in the US available both in print and digital form. Visit https://www.hispanicoutlook.com/education-magazine for information about our latest issue, including our new supplement Physician Outlook.
Hispanic Outlook’s Job Board allows applicants to search for jobs by category, by city and by state. Both Featured and Latest Job Positions are available at https://hispanicoutlookjobs.com/
And for employers, Hispanic Outlook’s Job Board offers a wide variety of posting options. Further information is available at https://hispanicoutlookjobs.com/employer-products/
Other articles from Hispanic Outlook:
Health Simplified And Expanded
The “on-boarding” process for this locum assignment turned out to be one of the most time-consuming and disorganized processes I’ve experienced to date. I was tasked with completing online EHR training for the hospital. The “playground” I was to do this training on had a “broken link,” and no matter how many times I tried to access it, I was unable to. I was getting emails left and right about my “delinquent status,” telling me I would have to do “remediative” training in person. Finally, after many trials and exasperated phone calls with IT, I was DONE. I had spent nearly six hours of my personal time trying to complete training for a temporary assignment that should have taken no more than an hour. I told my recruiter to sign me up for the in-person “Remediation” session with an IT specialist. I was jetlagged when drove almost two hours to the main hospital system’s IT training building where I attended a one-hour class with two other Physicians. Most of our questions could not be addressed by the trainer because it was “beyond her scope.” I was finally…
Read full article here
Inspiring and Aspiring Claudia Martinez
During my first year of undergrad, I was diagnosed with Chiari Malformation (a condition where a portion of the cerebellum herniates out of the bottom of the skull, compressing the brainstem) and Syringomyelia (the development of a fluid-filled cyst (syrinx) within the spinal cord). At the time, I had no idea my life would change forever. Since then, I’ve lived in and out of the hospital, sometimes hospitalized months at a time. I’ve undergone 6 major brain surgeries, 4 feeding tube surgeries, 5 shunt surgeries, multiple procedures, diagnostic tests, and have been diagnosed with Hydrocephalus (a buildup of too much cerebrospinal fluid in the brain), Trigeminal Neuralgia (a chronic pain condition that affects the 5th cranial nerve), Adrenal Insufficiency (a condition in which the adrenal glands do not produce adequate amounts of steroid hormones) and Tethered Brainstem (where the brainstem becomes pinned to the dura, the outer covering of the brain) along the way. In February 2017, I went in for my 6th brain surgery to fix a Tethered Brainstem I developed and…
Read full article here
Saluting Physicians And Volunteers
My experiences in Haiti could fill a book but let me just tell you this one that affected me directly. I was standing between two parked vehicles holding the door of one when another vehicle slammed into the side of one of the vehicles. It pushed the two vehicles together “pinching” my hand between the door I was holding and the second vehicle. After freeing my hand, the blood began flowing. Two of my fingers were “cut” almost to the bone on one side. This started a flurry of events. First, there were calls to find out where to go as there aren’t hospitals with emergency rooms, emergency clinics or even a working ambulance service in most communities, readily available. After several calls, I was told of a clinic to go to (a distance away and struggle to get to due to the poor infrastructure, traffic, etc.). I was able to secure a vehicle and driver to take me there. Upon arrival at the medical facility, I found the “emergency room” to be a single room with one bed and a couple of chairs. The floor was covered with blood, gauze, and there was a man in the bed that they had just…
Read full article here
Being Called To Serve Those In Need
You might ask why someone who is a contractor, professional driver, technical engineer, project manager would be writing an article for Physician Outlook; and that would be a legitimate question. The answer is one that will hopefully touch your heart and open your mind. Several years back while operating a successful building and grounds maintenance company, I was planning a trip for myself to go to the keys, to relax, scuba dive and just enjoy some of what life offers. It was all planned when I saw on television a clip that showed a town, Harrisburg, Illinois, devastated by a tornado/storm, and requests for volunteers needed to help. I just could not turn from it, I canceled my trip, called my mother, and told her what I was planning on doing and asked if she wanted to go; the next day we were driving from Pennsylvania to Illinois to help strangers in their distress. I will never forget driving into the town, and walking through the streets, realizing we are so “desensitized” to things through television, media, internet…the reality set in. We spent the next week…
Read full article here
Pediatrician Honored As Everyday Hero
Dr. David Hennessey, M.D., is a pediatrician who practiced at Sewickley Valley Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine in Wexford, Pennsylvania, and has volunteered his services in remote regions of Guatemala. He was in active practice for 45 years. Earlier this year, the Pennsylvania Medical Society (PAMED) selected Dr. Hennessey for one of its Everyday Hero Awards. Dr. Hennessey earned his medical degree from Jefferson Medical College in Philadelphia and completed a residency in pediatrics at the University of Cincinnati, Good Samaritan Hospital. His service to the community started with a four-year stint in the Air Force following his residency. After his military service ended, he decided that he wanted to bring pediatrics to a rural area where there is a desperate need for Doctors and spent time practicing in Titusville, Pennsylvania. He and his wife Anne then chose to settle in the Pittsburgh area. He joined Sewickley Valley Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine in Wexford (SVPAM) in 1986 and was an SVPAM partner. Dr. Hennessey practiced at…
Read full article here
